I’d start with the Hanes EcoSmart Blackout if you want substantial coverage, choose the Seasonless 40-denier tights for a lighter everyday look, and pick the Art Deco Control Top when pattern and gentle shaping matter most. All three bring recycled nylon into the tights mix, but they differ sharply in opacity, support, and how much visual detail they add to an outfit.
Get your wardrobe favorites delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
My ranking favors the Blackout for its clearly specified recycled content and practical opaque coverage, while the Seasonless pair is the easier pick for a polished sheer finish. The Art Deco option is the most expressive, though its 25-denier fabric calls for more careful handling. One detail deserves attention: the Seasonless and Art Deco descriptions mention recycled nylon and spandex, but their listed fiber percentages do not specify recycled content. I treat that distinction as a meaningful comparison, not a minor label detail.
Key Takeaways
- The Blackout is the clearest choice for buyers prioritizing documented recycled fiber content: its listed blend includes 87% recycled nylon and 8% recycled spandex.
- At 100 denier, the Blackout provides far more coverage than the 40-denier Seasonless and 25-denier Art Deco pairs, but may feel too warm for mild weather.
- The Seasonless tights offer the middle ground in opacity and a smooth, polished look, but the supplied fiber percentages do not identify which fibers are recycled.
- The Art Deco pair adds pattern, gentle control-top shaping, and a sheer finish; its lighter fabric may be less resistant to snags than the opaque option.
- All three have a sheer toe and require hand washing, so none is the best match for buyers who want machine-washable tights or a reinforced, fully opaque toe.
| Hanes EcoSmart Women’s Blackout Opaque Tights with Sheer Toe |  | Best Overall for Documented Recycled Content and Coverage | Fabric: 87% recycled nylon, 8% recycled spandex, 5% virgin spandex | Opacity: Opaque | Denier: 100 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hanes EcoSmart Seasonless Tights with Enhanced Panty, Sheer Toe, and Wide Waistband |  | Best for a Lighter Everyday Sheer Look | Fabric: 84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description | Denier: 40 | Toe style: Sheer toe | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hanes Women’s EcoSmart Art Deco Control Top Tights |  | Best for Pattern and Gentle Shaping | Fabric: 84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description | Denier: 25 | Style: Two patterns | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| recycled nylon tight | Fabric | Denier | Care | Origin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hanes EcoSmart Women’s Blackou | 87% recycled nylon, 8% recycled spandex, 5% virgin spandex | 100 | Hand wash only | Imported |
| Hanes EcoSmart Seasonless Tigh | 84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description | 40 | Hand wash only | Imported |
| Hanes Women’s EcoSmart Art Dec | 84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description | 25 | Hand wash only | Imported |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Hanes EcoSmart Women’s Blackout Opaque Tights with Sheer Toe
The Blackout is my lead pick because it combines the strongest coverage in this lineup with the clearest recycled-fiber breakdown. Its blend is listed as 87% recycled nylon, 8% recycled spandex, and 5% virgin spandex, making it the most transparent choice here for shoppers checking exactly what the fabric claim means. At 100 denier, it is also in a different category from the two sheer styles: expect a more covered leg, rather than the lighter, dressier finish of the Seasonless or Art Deco pair.
The wide waistband is intended to reduce pinching, and static-resistant technology may be useful when tights cling to skirts or dresses. A sheer toe gives it more flexibility with open-toe shoes than a fully opaque toe would. The tradeoff is seasonal: this heavier fabric may be uncomfortable on warmer days, and hand washing adds a care step. Compared with the Seasonless option, it offers much more coverage and better-documented recycled content, but not the same light appearance. Compared with the Art Deco pair, it favors simple, solid coverage over pattern and gentle control-top shaping.
I’d choose it when warmth, opacity, and a specific recycled blend matter more than a barely-there look. I would skip it for hot weather or outfits that call for delicate sheer hosiery.
Pros:- Lists 87% recycled nylon and 8% recycled spandex in the fabric blend.
- 100-denier opaque coverage suits outfits that need a more covered leg.
- Wide waistband is designed to reduce pinching and create a smoother fit.
- Static-resistant technology and sheer toe add practical styling flexibility.
Cons:- Hand-wash-only care takes more effort than machine-washable hosiery.
- The 100-denier fabric may feel too heavy in warmer weather.
Best for: Shoppers who want opaque black tights and the clearest listed recycled nylon and spandex percentages.
Not ideal for: Anyone seeking lightweight, warm-weather hosiery or tights that can be machine washed.
- Fabric:87% recycled nylon, 8% recycled spandex, 5% virgin spandex
- Opacity:Opaque
- Denier:100
- Waistband:Wide waistband
- Toe:Sheer toe
- Construction:Same-to-waist
- Care:Hand wash only
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I recommend the Blackout as the most compelling all-round choice here for buyers who value full coverage and clearly specified recycled content.”
Hanes EcoSmart Seasonless Tights with Enhanced Panty, Sheer Toe, and Wide Waistband
The Seasonless pair sits between the other two on coverage: its 40-denier finish is lighter than the Blackout’s 100 denier but more substantial than the Art Deco’s 25-denier sheer. That makes it the straightforward option for a smooth, polished look when full opaque coverage would feel too heavy. Its wide waistband is designed to stay in place without digging, and stretchy fabric supports movement through a workday or an event.
There is a useful difference between the product description and its spec line. The description says the tights are made with recycled nylon and spandex, but the listed fabric percentages are 84% nylon and 16% spandex, without specifying how much is recycled. I would not treat that as equivalent to the Blackout’s exact recycled-content breakdown. For a shopper whose priority is proving the recycled share from the available information, the Blackout is the more defensible pick. The Art Deco tights also list the same broad fiber percentages, but add pattern and control-top shaping at a lighter denier.
The sheer toe works with open-toe shoes, though this style does not have the Blackout’s opaque leg or the Art Deco pair’s patterned finish. Like both alternatives, it requires hand washing. I’d pick it for a simple, versatile sheer effect, but not if you need a fully documented recycled blend or a thicker, more protective feel.
Pros:- 40-denier coverage offers a middle ground between opaque and very sheer tights.
- Wide waistband is designed to resist pinching and digging.
- Stretchy fabric supports comfortable movement.
- Sheer toe can work with open-toe shoes.
Cons:- The listed fiber percentages do not specify the recycled share.
- Hand washing is required.
- It provides less coverage than the 100-denier Blackout.
Best for: Shoppers who want a versatile 40-denier sheer style with a wide waistband and a smoother look than very light hosiery.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need exact recycled-fiber percentages, opaque coverage, or machine-washable care.
- Fabric:84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description
- Denier:40
- Toe style:Sheer toe
- Waistband:Wide waistband
- Panty:Enhanced panty
- Color:Black
- Care:Hand wash only
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I’d choose the Seasonless tights for a balanced sheer finish, while treating their recycled-content claim as less precisely documented than the Blackout’s.”
Hanes Women’s EcoSmart Art Deco Control Top Tights
The Art Deco tights are the style-led choice: their 25-denier sheer finish and two timeless patterns add more visual interest than the solid Blackout or Seasonless styles. A control top provides gentle shaping, while the wide waistband is designed for a secure fit. If I wanted patterned hosiery that still has a classic black base, this pair would be the most distinctive option in the group.
That lighter finish changes the wearing tradeoff. At 25 denier, these tights look airier than the 40-denier Seasonless pair and far less covered than the 100-denier Blackout. The supplied product information also flags sheer coverage as potentially less durable than opaque tights, so I’d be more careful around rough surfaces and when dressing. The Blackout makes more sense when toughness and coverage come first; the Seasonless pair is the quieter choice for a plain, polished leg. Art Deco earns its place by bringing pattern and shaping, not by maximizing protection.
The description says the fabric uses recycled nylon and spandex, but its listed 84% nylon and 16% spandex blend does not state the recycled proportion. That makes the recycled claim less specific than the Blackout’s. As with the other two pairs, care is hand wash only, and the sheer toe can suit open-toe shoes. I’d buy this for its look and control-top feature, not for the most substantial coverage or the clearest recycled-fiber accounting.
Pros:- Two patterns offer more visual detail than the solid styles in this lineup.
- Control top provides gentle shaping.
- 25-denier finish creates a light, sheer appearance.
- Wide waistband and sheer toe support a secure fit and open-toe styling.
Cons:- Sheer fabric may be less durable than the opaque Blackout tights.
- The listed fiber percentages do not identify the recycled share.
- Hand-wash-only care requires extra attention.
Best for: Shoppers who want patterned sheer tights with gentle control-top shaping and a wide waistband.
Not ideal for: Anyone who prioritizes durable opaque coverage, a plain hosiery look, or exact recycled-content percentages.
- Fabric:84% nylon, 16% spandex; recycled content is claimed in the description
- Denier:25
- Style:Two patterns
- Features:Control top, sheer toe, wide waistband
- Color:Black
- Care:Hand wash only
- Origin:Imported
Our verdict“I recommend Art Deco when pattern and gentle shaping matter more than durability or a precisely quantified recycled blend.”
How We Picked
I ranked these options around the specific promise of recycled nylon tights, rather than treating any stretchy hosiery as interchangeable. I compared the stated fiber information, opacity, support features, toe construction, and care instructions. I gave extra weight to how clearly the recycled content is documented: the Blackout listing specifies recycled nylon and recycled spandex percentages, while the other two descriptions claim recycled material but list only nylon and spandex percentages without identifying the recycled share.
My order also reflects what each pair is designed to do. The 100-denier Blackout is the strongest choice for coverage and a more substantial feel; the 40-denier Seasonless pair targets a lighter, conventional sheer-tights look; and the 25-denier Art Deco style trades some toughness for pattern and shaping. All three use a wide waistband and sheer toe, so those shared details do not separate them as much as fabric weight and finish do. I have not inferred durability, fit range, or environmental credentials beyond the supplied product information.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Recycled Nylon Tights
I’d choose recycled nylon tights by looking beyond the sustainability wording: compare the stated recycled share, denier, and construction against the way you plan to wear them.Check what the recycled-content claim actually specifies
Among these three, the Blackout has the clearest material breakdown: the listing states 87% recycled nylon and 8% recycled spandex, alongside 5% virgin spandex. The Seasonless and Art Deco descriptions mention recycled materials, but their specs list only 84% nylon and 16% spandex. Those percentages describe the fiber mix, not how much of it is recycled. If documented recycled content is your main reason for buying, I’d favor the Blackout based on the supplied details and check the current label for the other styles before purchasing.
Recycled-fiber claims alone do not tell me how long a pair will last, how it was made, or its full environmental impact. I’d treat the composition as one useful buying detail rather than a complete sustainability score.
Match denier to coverage and weather
Denier helps explain the biggest visual difference in this group. The Blackout’s 100 denier is opaque and offers the most leg coverage; the Seasonless pair’s 40 denier lands in the middle; and Art Deco’s 25 denier is the sheerest. Higher coverage can suit cooler days or outfits where a solid black leg is part of the look, while lower denier gives a lighter finish.
Denier is not a guarantee of how a pair will feel or how long it will last, since fit and handling matter too. Still, it is a practical first filter: choose Blackout for opacity, Seasonless for moderate sheerness, and Art Deco for a lighter patterned appearance.
Decide whether shaping or a simple finish matters more
Both the Blackout and Seasonless tights are designed around a wide waistband, with the Seasonless listing an enhanced panty. Art Deco adds a control top for gentle shaping, so it is the clearest match if you want hosiery with a shaping feature. That support is a different priority from the Blackout’s extra coverage or the Seasonless pair’s middle-weight, understated finish.
Descriptions of waistband benefits do not establish how a particular size will fit every body. I’d check the available size information and return terms before choosing, especially if waistband comfort is a deciding factor.
Treat care and toe style as practical filters
All three require hand washing, so none suits a buyer looking for low-effort machine care. Gentle washing and careful handling are sensible for hosiery, especially the 25-denier Art Deco pair, which has a sheer finish and may be less durable than opaque tights. If regular hand washing feels like too much work, it may be worth comparing other products rather than choosing among these three.
Each option has a sheer toe, which can work with open-toe shoes. That shared feature makes toe styling less of a ranking factor here; instead, decide whether you want opaque, medium-sheer, or patterned sheer legs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which pair has the most clearly stated recycled content?
The Hanes EcoSmart Blackout is the clearest based on the supplied specifications: it lists 87% recycled nylon, 8% recycled spandex, and 5% virgin spandex. The Seasonless and Art Deco descriptions mention recycled nylon and spandex, but their listed percentages do not identify the recycled share. If exact composition matters to you, check the packaging or product label for the version you plan to buy.
Which of these recycled nylon tights is the most opaque?
The Blackout is the most opaque by a wide margin, with a 100-denier finish. Seasonless is 40 denier and Art Deco is 25 denier, so both look sheerer. I’d choose Blackout for fuller leg coverage and the lighter-denier styles when I want a more delicate appearance.
Are any of these tights designed for open-toe shoes?
All three list a sheer toe, so each is intended to work with open-toe footwear more easily than a style with a fully opaque toe. The rest of the leg still looks quite different: Blackout has opaque coverage, Seasonless has a 40-denier finish, and Art Deco is a patterned 25-denier sheer style.
Which pair offers control-top shaping?
The Art Deco tights are the one option in this lineup that specifically lists a control top, described as providing gentle shaping. The Blackout and Seasonless pairs both emphasize a wide waistband, but their supplied features do not list control-top construction. Choose Art Deco for that shaping detail, while recognizing its lighter sheer fabric may need more careful handling than the opaque Blackout.
Can I machine wash these Hanes EcoSmart tights?
The supplied care information says hand wash only for all three options. I would not assume that any of them are machine washable; follow the care label on the specific pair. This shared requirement is a real drawback if easy laundry care is high on your list.
Conclusion
For the clearest stated recycled blend and opaque coverage, I’d choose the Hanes EcoSmart Blackout, as long as its 100-denier weight suits the weather. If you want a straightforward, moderately sheer look, the Seasonless pair is the middle ground, but its recycled share is not quantified in the listed specs. For pattern and gentle control-top shaping, Art Deco is the standout, with a tradeoff in sheer-fabric durability. All three require hand washing, so buyers seeking machine care should look beyond this lineup.
